Viator Rating : 5 (155 reviews)
Dyvarcity Score : 7.1/10 (Solid Experience)
St Augustine
St. Augustine True Crime Pub Crawl: Blood & Cocktails!
120
Overview
Blood On The Cobblestones True Crime Tour of St Augustine invites guests to explore the darker side of America's oldest city. This true crime walking tour combines chilling tales of murder with refreshing drinks at some of St. Augustine’s best bars. It's a unique way to discover the shocking secrets hidden beneath the city's charming facade.
Guests will visit the sites of five different murders that happened in St. Augustine, including the Delany Murder Site, the Site of W.D. Lindsey Murder, the Juan Carlos Murder Site, the Athalia Lindsley Murder Site, and the Amy Blount Murder Site. At each stop, you'll learn about the crime, the victims, and any suspects involved. It's like stepping back in time to witness the events unfold.
This tour includes a guided true crime pub crawl of St. Augustine. Gratuities and alcoholic beverages are not included, and guests must be 21 or older to participate. This experience is perfect for true crime fans and anyone who wants to see a different side of St. Augustine. Discover why this city is not only the oldest but also one of the most haunted. 
Experience DNA Fingerprint
Scores are shown on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 = lowest score, 10 = highest score.
What People Love
Safety (8 - Secure) : Strong feeling of safety and control
Upsell Risk (8 - Transparent) : No upsells or hidden costs
Guide Quality (9 - Exceptional) : Engaging and memorable
Guide Reliability (8 - Dependable) : On time with strong follow-through
What to Watch Out For
Crowd Density (5 - Standard) : Normal crowd, some waiting or tight spots
Logistics (7 - Friction) : Issues but experience continued
Mobility (6 - Moderate) : Some effort required
Pacing (6 - Uneven) : Inconsistent or mixed pacing
Instagram Factor (7 - Scenic) : Some good photo moments
Highlights
True Crime Meets Pub Crawl: Sip on drinks while hearing about St. Augustine's darkest crimes.
Explore Murder Sites: Visit the locations where shocking murders took place.
Hear Unforgettable Stories: Discover the twisted tales of the Ancient City's underbelly.
Perfect for True Crime Fans: A must-do experience for anyone fascinated by crime history.
Sentiment Analysis
Guests love the spooky and interesting stories.
-
They think the tour guides are fun and know a lot about the city's history.
-
Many enjoy the mix of true crime stories and visiting local bars.
-
Some say it's a great way to see St. Augustine while learning something new.
Some guests didn't like walking in certain weather conditions.
-
A few people felt the stories could have been more detailed.
The Journey
Delany Murder Site, St. Augustine
Step back to 1785 and delve into Florida's oldest unsolved murder, the brutal Delany case. The site, though unmarked today, is steeped in the atmosphere of early St. Augustine, a time of sweltering heat and nascent community. Imagine the shockwaves that reverberated through the fledgling town. Visit this location to ponder the potential motives – revenge, greed, or something far more sinister – and decide for yourself what secrets still linger in the silence of this cold case. While the exact location is debated, the area near the Government House Museum provides a contextual backdrop, as it was the heart of the city during that era.
Site of W.D. Lindsey Murder, St. Augustine
Uncover the twisted tale of W.D. Lindsey at the location where a bullet echoed through history, forever staining the South with scandal and betrayal. This site, now a part of modern St. Augustine, once bore witness to a murder shrouded in mystery. Was it cold-blooded revenge or justice served in the shadows? Visitors can reflect on the chilling details of a crime that gripped the community, imagining the whispers and accusations that filled the air. The nearby St. George Street offers a glimpse into the historical atmosphere of the time, allowing visitors to immerse themselves in the setting of this dark chapter.
Juan Carlos Murder Site, St. Augustine
Venture into the heart of 1800s St. Augustine and explore the chilling story of Juan Carlos, a trusted figure whose life ended in a dark tale of deceit and deadly consequences. Though the exact location is unknown, imagine the cobblestone streets filled with shock and whispers following the grim discovery. Visitors can walk through the historic district, piecing together the layers of a crime that shook the oldest city in America. Explore the Spanish Quarter Museum to better understand the environment and society in which this tragic event unfolded, and to feel the lingering echoes of betrayal that history tried to bury.
Athalia Lindsley Murder Site, St. Augustine
Visit the location of the 1974 broad-daylight murder of Athalia Lindsley, a former model and political firebrand, which stunned St. Augustine. Just steps from her home, she was brutally killed, yet no one was ever convicted. Reflect on the possibilities – a crime of passion, revenge, or the result of powerful figures remaining silent. This site, though now transformed, serves as a haunting reminder of one of Florida’s most infamous unsolved murders. A visit to the nearby Lightner Museum provides insight into the social and political climate of the era, helping visitors grasp the terror that may lie in what was left unsaid and the impact of this case on the community.
Amy Blount Murder Site, St. Augustine
Reflect on the brutal murder of Amy Blount, which shattered the illusion of safety in 1990s St. Augustine. What began as an ordinary night ended in unthinkable violence, leaving a community reeling. The site, within the quiet charm of Florida's oldest city, stands as a reminder of the fragility of peace and the long-lasting impact of violence. This location, though potentially unmarked, invites visitors to contemplate the harrowing details of the case that shook St. Augustine to its core. A visit to the St. Augustine Police Department (non-emergency, public access areas) can provide further context and insight into modern crime-solving efforts in the historic city.
Know Before You Go
This true crime pub crawl includes a guided walking tour of St. Augustine's most notorious crime scenes. Please note that gratuities and alcoholic beverages are not included in the tour price. This tour is exclusively for guests aged 21 and older. The meeting point will be provided after booking. Get ready to explore the dark side of the Ancient City!
Hot Tip
Wear comfy shoes, as you'll be walking between bars. It's also a good idea to check the weather and dress for the conditions. Some guests also suggest having a snack before the tour, since drinks are included but food is not.
Review Summary
People usually say this tour is exactly what true crime enthusiasts are looking for, with praise centered on knowledgeable and engaging guides who take time to answer questions and share fascinating historical details about St. Augustine's unsolved murders and dark past[2]. The tour ranks highly among St. Augustine's top crime tours and is frequently recommended for its unique blend of history, mystery, and local bar experiences in the nation's oldest city[3][4]. Most travelers appreciate the immersive storytelling and the way guides bring cold cases to life while walking through authentic historic crime scenes[5].
This page is synthesized and developed by Dyvarcity Team
More like this
St Augustine
$159
Savor St. Augustine: A Perfect Pairing of History, Food, and Spirits
5.0
(1227 reviews)
Duration: 210
minutes
St. Augustine's Wine, Cocktail and Food Experience blends history with culinary delights. Explore picturesque streets while enjoying cocktails, cheese, charcuterie, and dishes inspired by global travels. This half-day small-group walking tour offers an excellent quality, intimate tasting experience.
St Augustine
$89
St. Augustine Sweets & History: A Delicious Walk
5.0
(273 reviews)
Duration: 90
minutes
St. Augustine's Sweets & History Walking Tour offers a delightful journey through the heart of historic St. Augustine, combining the pleasure of unique sweets and chocolates with captivating local stories. This walking tour is perfect for anyone who loves chocolate and history.
Expect to discover the city's best sweet treats while strolling past iconic landmarks. The tour visits Government House, where you can admire the architecture. Then the tour heads to the Town Plaza (Plaza de la Constitución), the central gathering place of St. Augustine. Other tour stops include the Ponce de Leon Hotel (Flagler College), St. George Street, Cathedral Basilica of St. Augustine, and St. Photios Greek Orthodox National Shrine. Along the way, hear fascinating stories from knowledgeable local guides.
The tour provides a variety of samplings, with extras to take home. The experience includes bottled water, snacks, and coffee or tea. Gratuities are not included. It's a delicious way to explore St. Augustine's rich heritage.
St Augustine
$129
Uncover St. Augustine's History: A Beer Lover's Walking Tour
5.0
(129 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
St. Augustine Beer & History Crawl: Explore America's oldest city, blending craft beer tasting with 450 years of historical discovery. Enjoy a guided walking tour through St. Augustine's charming streets, sampling local Florida brews. Perfect for history buffs and beer enthusiasts seeking a unique, small-group experience with drinks and snacks.
St Augustine
$135
St. Augustine Corks & Forks: Food & Drink Walking Tour
4.9
(730 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Corks & Forks Tour (St. Augustine) offers a delightful 'Progressive Style', Seated Food Adventure. This walking tour invites guests to savor St. Augustine's vibrant food scene through a curated tasting experience. This culinary journey visits four carefully selected venues, each presenting a dish bursting with bold flavors, paired with exquisite wines or artisanal cocktails.
Guests will leisurely stroll through St. Augustine's charming streets, taking in the city's beauty while enjoying insider insights from a local culinary expert. The tour includes key stops like the historic Government House and other hidden gems within the St. Augustine Foodie Tour scene. Expect a blend of culinary exploration with a touch of local history and sightseeing.
This experience includes alcoholic beverages, lunch, and dinner. It excludes tour host gratuity, and unfortunately, no pets are allowed. Participants must be 21+; the tour requires a minimum of 4 people to depart. This tour is perfect for those seeking an intimate and high-quality culinary experience in St. Augustine.
Orlando
$89
Savor Orlando: A Delicious Food Tour of Ivanhoe Village
5.0
(38 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Embark on the Ivanhoe Village Food Tour for a flavorful exploration of Orlando's culinary scene. Sample creations from 6 local eateries and visit 2 shops while uncovering the district's history. Enjoy a half-day of food, hidden gems, and insights into Ivanhoe Village's vibrant character.
St Augustine
$155
St. Augustine Culinary Journey: Wine & Dine Electric Vehicle Tour
4.9
(251 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
The Wine & Dine Tour in St. Augustine offers a luxurious culinary exploration via open-air electric vehicle. Enjoy exclusive tastings at four top venues with a local guide, uncovering food history and hidden gems. This 21+ experience focuses on the culinary scene with history sprinkled in. Perfect for food enthusiasts!
Nearby Events
Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts - Moran Theater
Nov 21
7:30 PMProfessor Brian Cox: Emergence Tour in Jacksonville
Professor Brian Cox brings his groundbreaking Emergence World Tour to the Jacksonville Center for the Performing Arts – Moran Theater, delivering a live experience that blends cosmology, philosophy, and stunning visuals. Known for his record-breaking Horizons tour and his ability to make complex science accessible, Cox explores the laws of nature, the origins of the universe, and the intricate beauty of life itself in this ambitious new show.
Emergence is celebrated for its immersive production, featuring state-of-the-art LED screens, captivating soundscapes, and collaborations with leading scientists and artists. The Moran Theater, a historic venue in downtown Jacksonville, is renowned for its excellent acoustics and intimate atmosphere, making it the perfect setting for Cox’s thought-provoking performance.
VyStar Ballpark
Mar 24
6:00 PMUF vs FSU Baseball: VyStar Ballpark Tickets
UF v FSU Baseball pits the Florida Gators Baseball against the Florida State Seminoles Baseball in a heated rivalry game at VyStar Ballpark. This Sunshine State showdown showcases two powerhouse college programs known for their intense competition and talented rosters, drawing fans eager for high-stakes action.
The Florida Gators and Florida State Seminoles boast storied histories in college baseball, with multiple NCAA appearances and regional showdowns fueling their legacy. VyStar Ballpark, home of the Jacksonville Jumbo Shrimp, offers a professional-grade setting with excellent sightlines.
Florida Theatre Jacksonville
May 01
7:30 PMTheresa Caputo Live at Florida Theatre Jacksonville
Theresa Caputo, the renowned Long Island Medium, brings her acclaimed live show to the Florida Theatre Jacksonville, offering an unforgettable evening of healing messages and spiritual connection. Known for her TLC reality series and best-selling books, Caputo has spent over two decades helping people find comfort by relaying messages from loved ones who have passed on. Her unique blend of candid storytelling, humor, and intimate readings continues to captivate audiences nationwide.
Caputo’s live experience is celebrated for its emotional depth and authenticity, as she channels spirit guides and delivers personal messages to audience members. The Florida Theatre Jacksonville, a historic venue known for its elegant architecture and excellent acoustics, provides the perfect setting for this special event, making it a must-see for fans of the paranormal and those seeking closure and connection.
Florida Theatre Jacksonville
Apr 01
7:00 PMAli Wong Live in Jacksonville - April 2026 Tickets
Ali Wong Live brings the Emmy award-winning comedian to Florida Theatre Jacksonville for an unforgettable night of stand-up comedy. Wong, celebrated for her irreverent and incisive humor exploring cultural identity, motherhood, and sexuality, continues her reign as one of entertainment's most compelling voices. Her explosive comedic talent has made her a household name, and this Jacksonville performance promises the same raw authenticity that has captivated audiences across her Netflix specials and sold-out tours.
Known for performing while pregnant with her children and capturing those intimate moments in her specials, Ali Wong has redefined what it means to be a working mother in comedy. Her 2024 special "Single Lady" earned her a Golden Globe Award, cementing her status as a cultural force. The Florida Theatre Jacksonville, a premier arts venue in Jacksonville, FL, provides an intimate setting for Wong's boundary-pushing comedy that tackles everything from personal struggles to broader social commentary.
Daytona International Speedway
Aug 29
7:30 PMCoke Zero Sugar 400 at Daytona: NASCAR's Playoff Finale
The NASCAR Cup Series Coke Zero Sugar 400 at Daytona International Speedway is the regular season finale where the stars of NASCAR battle under the lights for their final chance to secure a playoff spot. This 160-lap, 400-mile race features unpredictable pack-style racing and high-stakes competition, with drivers competing in a "win and you're in" scenario where every competitor has an equal shot at making the NASCAR playoffs. The intensity builds throughout the entire field as competitors search for that crucial victory.
The 2025 race showcased dramatic finishes and pivotal moments, with Ryan Blaney surging from 13th place to claim victory in the final two laps by just 0.031 seconds. Daytona International Speedway, known as the "World Center of Racing" and America's most iconic racetrack, provides the perfect stage for this cornerstone event on the NASCAR schedule. Attendees can combine this with the Friday night Wawa 250 for the NASCAR O'Reilly Auto Parts Series to create an unforgettable summer racing doubleheader.
Colonial Oak Music Park
May 20
6:00 PMProtoje & Jesse Royal Live at Colonial Oak
Protoje with Jesse Royal brings 'The Reggae Invasion' to Colonial Oak Music Park in St. Augustine, blending Jamaica's reggae heritage with hip-hop, soul, and jazz influences. Protoje, backed by The Indiggnation, delivers visionary performances from albums like In Search of Lost Time, a Grammy-nominated dub exploration, promising an electrifying night of modern roots music.
Protoje stands as a pivotal figure in Jamaica's musical renaissance, redefining reggae through innovative soundscapes that fuse tradition with contemporary genres. Jesse Royal complements with his dynamic energy, creating a powerhouse bill. Colonial Oak Music Park offers an intimate outdoor setting in historic St. Augustine, perfect for immersive live shows.
The Bucket List Playbook: Top Things to do in Jacksonville
Ready for adventure? Dyvarcity is your ultimate guide to the top 100 things to do in Jacksonville From must-see attractions like Short Term Availability, Music, New Product & Sports in Jacksonville. We've handpicked events & experiences with passion: whether you love activities that move your body, vibrant music, sports, food, or cultural explorations.
View Jacksonville Activities