Viator Rating : 5 (1196 reviews)
Dyvarcity Score : 7.4/10 (Solid Experience)
New York City
NYC Mafia Tour: Food, Crime & NYPD Stories
210
Overview
The New York City Mafia and Local Food Tour led by NYPD Guides offers a unique experience to explore the city's dark history and delicious cuisine. This isn't your typical tour; it's a 'walk with stories' led by active and retired NYPD officers and local residents who have firsthand knowledge of the mafia's presence in New York City.
On this tour, participants will walk the streets where infamous mafia figures once strolled, visiting notorious crime locations in the East Village and Little Italy. The tour begins at a famous Mafia "Red Sauce Joint," like those seen in "The Sopranos" and "Get Gotti." Expect to visit iconic locations such as John's of 12th Street, St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery, the Basilica of Saint Patrick's Old Cathedral, and the Little Italy Movie Backdrop. Participants will hear true crime stories and enjoy authentic food from the neighborhood, equivalent to a full three-course dinner.
This half-day walking tour includes spaghetti and meatballs, eggplant rollatini parm, and a Sicilian cannoli. Headsets are provided to ensure everyone can hear the insider stories from retired NYPD guides and NYC mafia experts. Vegetarian options are available with advanced request. The tour accommodates a small group size and is suitable for those interested in historical tours and true crime stories. 
Experience DNA Fingerprint
Scores are shown on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 = lowest score, 10 = highest score.
What People Love
Safety (9 - Secure) : Strong feeling of safety and control
Upsell Risk (9 - Transparent) : No upsells or hidden costs
Guide Quality (9 - Exceptional) : Engaging and memorable
Guide Reliability (9 - Dependable) : On time with strong follow-through
What to Watch Out For
Crowd Density (4 - Standard) : Normal crowd, some waiting or tight spots
Logistics (7 - Friction) : Issues but experience continued
Mobility (6 - Moderate) : Some effort required
Pacing (7 - Uneven) : Inconsistent or mixed pacing
Instagram Factor (7 - Scenic) : Some good photo moments
Highlights
Real NYPD Guides: Hear firsthand stories from retired NYPD officers and local Mafia experts.
Delicious Italian Food: Enjoy a full 3-course dinner with spaghetti and meatballs, eggplant rollatini parm, and cannoli.
Iconic Mafia Locations: Walk the streets of Little Italy and the East Village, visiting famous crime spots.
Headsets Provided: Don't miss any details with provided headsets ensuring clear audio during the tour.
Sentiment Analysis
Customers love hearing real stories from the guides.
-
Many enjoyed the food, calling it a highlight.
-
Visitors appreciated seeing real Mafia spots and learning about the history.
-
Customers found the tour guides very knowledgable about the Mafia
Some found that drinks not being included added extra cost.
-
Some customers would have preferred more time in the various locations.
The Journey
John's of 12th Street
Step back in time at John's of 12th Street, a legendary 'Red Sauce Joint' in the East Village with a rich history intertwined with the Italian Mafia. Founded in 1908, this iconic restaurant served as a speakeasy during Prohibition, and a notorious meeting place for mobsters, including the site of the 1922 assassination of Umberto Rocco Valenti. Experience the old-world charm, indulge in classic Italian dishes, and soak in the atmosphere that has made John's a favorite among locals and a popular filming location for shows like 'Boardwalk Empire' and 'The Sopranos'.
Manhattan Island
Explore the heart of New York City on Manhattan Island, the smallest and most densely populated borough. As the economic, administrative, and cultural hub, Manhattan boasts iconic landmarks, world-class museums, bustling financial districts, and vibrant entertainment venues. From the towering skyscrapers of Midtown to the historic streets of Lower Manhattan, immerse yourself in the energy and excitement that define this global metropolis.
St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery
Discover a haven of tranquility at St. Mark's Church in-the-Bowery, a historic Episcopal parish in the East Village. As the oldest site of continuous religious practice in New York City, dating back to the mid-17th century, this architectural gem offers a glimpse into the city's spiritual past. Admire its stunning architecture, explore its serene grounds, and attend a service or event to experience the church's vibrant community and artistic legacy.
East Village and Lower East Side Tenements
Delve into the history of immigration and urbanization in the East Village and Lower East Side. During the 19th century, this area transformed into one of the most densely populated in the city, marked by subdivided tenements. Walk the streets and reflect on the stories of countless immigrants who shaped the cultural fabric of New York City.
Basilica of Saint Patrick's Old Cathedral
Visit the Basilica of Saint Patrick's Old Cathedral, a historic Catholic church and former cathedral of the Archdiocese of New York, located in Nolita. Built between 1809 and 1815 in the Gothic Revival style, this architectural masterpiece showcases stunning stained glass windows, intricate details, and a peaceful atmosphere. Explore the basilica's rich history, attend a mass, or simply admire its beauty and significance.
Little Italy
Experience the vibrant flavors and traditions of Little Italy, a historic neighborhood in Lower Manhattan. Although its Italian character has diminished in recent decades, Little Italy still offers a taste of authentic Italian cuisine, culture, and community. Don't miss the annual Feast of San Gennaro, a lively celebration held every year following Labor Day, with food stalls, music, and entertainment along Mulberry Street. Explore the filming locations of movies like 'The Godfather Part II' and savor the essence of Italian heritage in the heart of New York City.
Little Italy Movie Backdrop
Capture unforgettable photos against the iconic backdrop of Little Italy. These buildings, featured in countless movies and TV series, provide a unique opportunity to immerse yourself in the neighborhood's cinematic history. Explore the streets, discover hidden gems, and create lasting memories in this culturally rich and visually stunning location.
Cannoli at Little Italy
Indulge in a classic Sicilian treat at Little Italy: a full-sized cannoli. Experience the perfect combination of a crispy shell and creamy, sweet filling. Sample the flavors of old-world Italian baking and savor a moment of pure culinary delight in this historic neighborhood.
Know Before You Go
This New York City Mafia and Local Food Tour includes spaghetti and meatballs, eggplant rollatini parm, and a Sicilian cannoli. Participants will get to hear insider stories from retired NYPD guides and NYC Mafia experts. Headsets are provided. Vegetarian options are available with advanced request. Drinks and gratuities are not included and can be purchased on the day. Transportation is not included. The meeting point is at a central location in Manhattan.
Hot Tip
Wear comfortable shoes, as this is a walking tour. Bring extra money for drinks and tips. If you have dietary restrictions, inform the tour operator in advance to accommodate vegetarian options. Be prepared to hear real-life stories that may be a bit intense.
Review Summary
People finds this tour exceptional for its authentic NYPD-guided mafia stories and generous food portions equivalent to a full dinner, with frequent praise for engaging guides like Dennis and Frank who share personal experiences from Little Italy streets.[1][2][3][4] Highlights include true crime details, cannoli, and insider access not found elsewhere; minor notes mention strong language and walking distance, but 98% recommend it as NYC's top experience with over 2,200 five-star ratings.[5][6]
This page is synthesized and developed by Dyvarcity Team
More like this
Philadelphia
$45
Philly's Liberty History Tour: Pub Crawl Adventure!
5.0
(294 reviews)
Duration: 135
minutes
Liberty History Tour Pub Crawl in Philadelphia is not your typical history lesson. This is a fun walking tour where you’ll explore Old City Philadelphia Bars with a local expert while enjoying drinks.
Get ready to uncover the hidden stories of Philadelphia, like a Founding Mother, a sneaky Ben Franklin, and the spies who helped America win the Revolution. The tour visits iconic landmarks and historic bars in Old City Philadelphia, making history come alive.
This experience includes alcoholic beverages to enjoy at the bars (guests can still buy drinks from the bars if they choose the dry run). The tour is approximately 2 hours and 15 minutes long, offering a tipsy journey through the City of Brotherly Love.
Philadelphia
$61
Philly's Italian Market Food Tour: Taste, See & Explore!
5.0
(289 reviews)
Duration: 150
minutes
Philadelphia Italian Market Public Food Tour: Explore one of Philly's most exciting neighborhoods! Since the 1800s, 9th Street has been the heart of the community. Now, it's time to taste the local flavors as an expert guide shares the amazing stories of the market's past. Get ready to enjoy five tasty bites that show off what this area has to offer.
What can people expect? It's a food adventure through the best of Philly's diverse food scene! Guests will try Italian classics like tomato pie from Sarcone's Bakery and sweet treats from Termini Bros. Bakery. Then, the adventure takes a flavorful turn with Mexican tacos and fresh tortillas from a local Mexican Cuisine Spot, and savory Vietnamese Banh Mi sandwiches from local Banh Mi Restaurants. Along the way, enjoy public art nestled in the backstreets and alleys.
This tour includes lunch, a banh mi sandwich, Italian classics like tomato pie, cannoli, or gelato, and Latin American flavors like spicy pollo pibil taco or fresh tortilla shells with guacamole. Also included is a laid-back stroll through one of the largest and oldest outdoor food markets in the country with a local, English-speaking guide. Gratuities and additional food and drinks are not included. Not all locations listed are guaranteed stops. It is important to wear comfortable shoes, bring an appetite, and enjoy the experience.
New York City
$90
Explore Authentic Chinatown: A Culinary Walking Adventure
5.0
(81 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
The Ultimate Chinatown Walking Food Tour explores Cantonese & Fujianese areas, plus Little Italy. Enjoy diverse flavors and cultural insights on this half-day adventure. Includes lunch, snacks, and drinks. Dietary needs are accommodated with advance notice. A unique culinary experience in NYC.
Philadelphia
$59
Philly Food Tour: Cheesesteaks & Reading Terminal Market
4.9
(849 reviews)
Duration: 150
minutes
The Center City Philadelphia Food Tour with Reading Market is a tasty walk through one of America's best food cities. This tour takes people around the lively Center City to taste five different foods that show off Philadelphia's amazing food scene. A big part of the tour is inside the Reading Terminal Market, a huge place filled with stands selling foods from all over the world.
Visitors can expect to taste true Philly favorites like the world-famous cheesesteak and soft pretzels. There might also be new and interesting foods to try, like tahini shakes or gluten-free cheese curds. The tour also shows off Philadelphia's diverse food culture. People might get to enjoy Japanese inari, Georgian soup dumplings, or Caribbean chicken patties. If anyone loves sweets, the tour guide knows where to find the best Amish whoopie pies, Italian cannoli, or amazing donuts.
The tour includes a walk through Center City and visits to places like the Masonic Temple of Philadelphia & City Hall and Philadelphia City Hall. It also stops at Reading Terminal Market, a new foodie hotspot, and innovative Philly eateries. Other possible stops include a vegan shake spot, a fried chicken restaurant, an Afghan eatery, a cheesesteak joint (Rittenhouse), a donut shop, a gluten-free bakery, a Georgian restaurant, an Amish pretzel vendor, a donut bakery, a Central American street food vendor, an Italian bakery, and a Jamaican eatery. This tour includes a Philly cheesesteak, soft pretzels, donuts, and other great tastes and lunch. A local, English-speaking guide leads the way to local-only food spots in Philadelphia. Keep in mind that gratuities and extra food and drinks are not included and that not all locations listed are guaranteed stops.
New York City
$74.8
Chelsea Market & High Line Food Tour: Eat & Explore NYC
4.9
(821 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Chelsea Market and High Line Guided Food Tour offers a tasty walk through some of New York City's coolest spots! This tour is all about yummy food and seeing awesome places. It's perfect for people who want to try new foods and learn about the city.
Get ready to explore Chelsea Market & Meatpacking District, The High Line, and Hudson Yards & Vessel. At Chelsea Market, there are many different foods. The High Line is a park built on old train tracks high above the city. Hudson Yards has cool buildings and shops to see. This tour is a fun way to see, walk, and eat around New York City!
This experience includes a local and professional guide and lunch to enjoy and exclude gratuities, offering a complete and memorable experience.
New York City
$60.16
Lower East Side Food Tour: Taste NYC's History
4.8
(1030 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Taste The American Dream: A Lower East Side Food Tour is a 3-hour walking adventure through New York City's most flavorful neighborhood. This isn't just about eating; it's a journey through time, culture, and the stories behind each delicious bite. Participants will explore the vibrant Lower East Side, Chinatown, and Little Italy, discovering hidden gems and iconic landmarks.
What to Expect: The tour guide, a friendly local food lover, leads small groups through a sensory experience. Expect to see and learn about places like the African Burial Ground National Monument, Foley Square, Columbus Park & Five Points, and the bustling streets of Chinatown and Little Italy. The adventure continues through Nolita, showcasing the Original St. Patrick's Old Cathedral, Sara D. Roosevelt Park, and the colorful Lower East Side street art. The tour makes sure that participants visit the famous Tenement Museum.
Included in the experience is a sampling of four historic dishes at four food stops, such as dumplings, pizza, knish, and empanadas. People will also get an inside look at a 100-year-old bakery, churches, and other historic New York sites. Keep in mind that gratuities, drinks, and extra food are not included. With the help of an expert guide, participants will gain insider tips on what else to see, do, and eat during their stay in New York City.
Nearby Events
Dream Live at American Dream
Aug 23
7:00 PMHigh School Musical Sing Along Tickets East Rutherford
High School Musical Sing Along! at Dream Live at American Dream brings the beloved Disney phenomenon to East Rutherford in an interactive sing-along format that turns the crowd into part of the show. With ticket listings already appearing for the East Rutherford stop, this event taps into the long-running popularity of High School Musical and the excitement around live audience participation.
High School Musical remains a defining name in family-friendly musical entertainment, known for its catchy songs, big ensemble moments, and a fan base that spans generations. Dream Live at American Dream is part of the American Dream entertainment complex in East Rutherford, a high-traffic destination that adds shopping, dining, and attraction-filled energy to the live-event experience.
Prudential Center
July 25
8:00 PMIVE World Tour in Newark | Prudential Center
IVE WORLD TOUR
IVE has become known for confident, stylish performances and a sleek sound that blends hook-heavy pop with modern K-pop production. Prudential Center is one of New Jersey’s top live entertainment venues, with a strong reputation for major concerts, easy transit access in Newark, and a large-scale arena setup that suits a world-tour production.
Madison Square Garden
July 18
7:30 PMWWE Monday Night RAW at Madison Square Garden
WWE Monday Night RAW comes to Madison Square Garden in New York, delivering one of the most anticipated wrestling spectacles of the year. This episode marks a crucial stop on the Road to WrestleMania 41, featuring some of WWE's biggest stars including World Heavyweight Champion GUNTHER, Women's World Champion Rhea Ripley, and 2025 Royal Rumble Winner Jey Uso in intense showdowns that will shape the landscape of professional wrestling's biggest annual event. The stakes are extraordinarily high as rivalries intensify and surprise appearances become a real possibility.
Madison Square Garden holds an unmatched legacy in professional wrestling history, having hosted iconic moments from Hulk Hogan slamming Andre the Giant to the birth of the Stone Cold Steve Austin era. This legendary venue continues to be WWE's premier destination, creating an electric atmosphere where unforgettable moments are born and wrestling history is made.
UBS Arena
July 31
4:00 PMGet Tickets: PFLMMA Live at UBS Arena July 2026
PFL New York Presented by Arkham brings professional fighters led by PFLMMA to the electrifying UBS Arena in Belmont Park, NY. This premier mixed martial arts event showcases the 2026 season's most intense competition, featuring global stars and rising contenders in a high-stakes tournament format that defines PFL's revolutionary approach to MMA entertainment.
PFLMMA represents the pinnacle of professional fighting, known for its unprecedented playoff system where champions must earn their titles through consistent performance across multiple events. The 2026 season marks the biggest year in PFL history with 24 total events and 16 global shows broadcast on ESPN, cementing the league's dominance in combat sports. UBS Arena, located within the historic Belmont Park venue, is renowned for its state-of-the-art facilities and immersive atmosphere that brings fans closer to the action.
New Jersey Performing Arts Center
Nov 05
8:00 PMDante Gebel World Tour Despedida 2026 Newark
Dante Gebel - World Tour Despedida 2026 brings the renowned Argentine motivational speaker and entertainer to the New Jersey Performing Arts Center in Newark for what promises to be an unforgettable evening of inspiration, humor, and personal transformation. Known for his dynamic stage presence and ability to connect with audiences across cultural and linguistic barriers, Gebel has built a global following through his unique blend of comedy, motivational speaking, and spiritual messages that resonate with diverse communities. This tour marks a significant moment in his career, offering fans an opportunity to experience his signature storytelling and transformative insights live.
Dante Gebel has become one of the most influential voices in the Hispanic entertainment and motivational speaking world, with millions of followers across social media platforms and a track record of sold-out events across North America, Latin America, and beyond. His presentations are known for combining humor with profound life lessons, making them appealing to families, young professionals, and spiritual seekers alike. The New Jersey Performing Arts Center, located in Newark's cultural district, provides an intimate yet impressive venue for this landmark event.
Toyota Oakdale Theatre
Sep 24
7:30 PMLabyrinth in Concert 40th: Toyota Oakdale Tickets
Jim Henson's Labyrinth: In Concert 40th Anniversary lights up the Toyota Oakdale Theatre with a magical fusion of cult classic film and live music. Fans watch the full 1986 fantasy masterpiece on a stunning HD screen as a live band performs David Bowie’s original vocals and Trevor Jones’ sweeping score in perfect sync, bringing iconic songs like 'Magic Dance' to life.[2][3] This 60-city North American tour celebrates 40 years since Jim Henson directed the beloved adventure starring Jennifer Connelly as Sarah and Bowie as the Goblin King Jareth, featuring fantastical creatures from Henson’s Creature Shop.[2][6]
Jim Henson's Labyrinth remains a timeless cult favorite for its enchanting story of bravery and whimsy in a goblin-filled maze. The Toyota Oakdale Theatre, a premier Connecticut venue, offers an intimate setting for this nostalgic spectacle.[1][2]
The Bucket List Playbook: Top Things to do in Brooklyn
Ready for adventure? Dyvarcity is your ultimate guide to the top 100 things to do in Brooklyn From must-see attractions like Short Term Availability, Music, Walking Tours & Rock in Brooklyn. We've handpicked events & experiences with passion: whether you love activities that move your body, vibrant music, sports, food, or cultural explorations.
View Brooklyn Activities