Viator Rating : 5 (829 reviews)
Dyvarcity Score : 7.8/10 (Solid Experience)
New York City
NYC Mafia Walk: True Crime, Food & Retired NYPD
180
Overview
True Crime NYC: Mafia Walk with Ret. NYPD Detective & Local Food takes people into the real world of the New York City Mafia. This walking tour, led by retired NYPD detectives and people who lived in Little Italy, shows spots other tours miss. The tour gives an insider’s look at the East Village and Little Italy's crime history.
What to Expect: The experience starts with a special tasting at a famous Mafia "Red Sauce Joint" seen in shows like "The Sopranos" and "Life After Goodfellas." Guests taste spaghetti at one of NYC's oldest Italian restaurants. The tour visits notorious Mafia and crime spots, sharing true stories about the neighborhood's gang history. Stops include the East Village Mafia origins, Second Avenue Prohibition history, an urban garden in Little Italy, the Gambino Family Social Club, and a taste of Sicilian cannoli.
What's Included: The tour includes a spaghetti tasting, snacks, and stories from retired NYPD guides who are NYC Mafia experts. It operates in all weather. What's Excluded: Gratuities and drinks are not included, but drinks can be bought during the tour. 
Experience DNA Fingerprint
Scores are shown on a scale of 1 to 10, 1 = lowest score, 10 = highest score.
What People Love
Safety (9 - Secure) : Strong feeling of safety and control
Upsell Risk (9 - Transparent) : No upsells or hidden costs
Mobility (8 - Easy / Accessible) : Comfortable for most people
Guide Quality (9 - Exceptional) : Engaging and memorable
Guide Reliability (8 - Dependable) : On time with strong follow-through
What to Watch Out For
Crowd Density (6 - Standard) : Normal crowd, some waiting or tight spots
Logistics (7 - Friction) : Issues but experience continued
Pacing (7 - Uneven) : Inconsistent or mixed pacing
Instagram Factor (7 - Scenic) : Some good photo moments
Highlights
Eat Like a Mobster: Enjoy a spaghetti tasting at a real Mafia restaurant.
Hear Real Mafia Stories: Listen to true crime stories from retired NYPD detectives.
See Secret Spots: Visit hidden locations known only to locals and insiders.
Walk Through History: Explore the East Village and Little Italy's crime history.
Sentiment Analysis
Guides share interesting stories about the Mafia.
-
Food tastings are a fun part of the tour.
-
The guides are knowledgeable and engaging.
-
People get to see real Mafia hangouts.
Some people wish there was more food.
-
The tour might be too long for some.
The Journey
East Village & Little Italy
Delve into the heart of New York's Mafia history with a walking tour through the East Village and Little Italy. Discover the notorious stomping grounds of infamous Mafia leaders like Lucky Luciano, Myer Lansky, Joe Bonnano, and John Gotti. This immersive experience offers a rare glimpse into the clandestine world of organized crime, enhanced by a traditional, full-sized cannoli from a local bakery, a far cry from typical tourist fare.
NYC "Red Sauce Joint" (302 E 12th Street)
Begin your Mafia pilgrimage at a classic NYC 'Red Sauce Joint' on 302 E 12th Street, a historic haunt frequented by members of New York's most powerful crime families and purportedly founded by Lucky Luciano himself. Immerse yourself in the authentic atmosphere where underworld history was made, starting with a welcoming plate of spaghetti.
East Village Mafia Origins
Unravel the complex origins of the Mafia in New York City within the vibrant streets of the East Village. Explore the intricate hierarchies of each crime family, from the foot soldiers to the capos and the 'Boss.' Walk in the footsteps of famed mobsters like Lucky Luciano, Joe 'the Boss' Masseria, John Gotti, 'Vinny the Chin,' and 'Crazy Joe' Gallo, and delve into their dramatic lives and notorious crimes.
Second Avenue Prohibition History
Step back in time and explore Second Avenue's rich Prohibition history. Discover hidden gems and lesser-known spots along this famous avenue, revealing the secrets and stories of a bygone era of speakeasies, mobsters, and illicit activities often missed by typical tours. A chance to see a different side of the city's past.
Urban Garden (Little Italy)
Discover an unexpected connection between a thriving urban garden and the New York Mafia in the heart of Little Italy. Uncover the intriguing story of how this green oasis ties into the history and operations of organized crime in the city, revealing a unique and surprising facet of the neighborhood's past.
Gambino Family Social Club (Little Italy)
Gain insider insights into the Gambino crime family and the enigmatic John Gotti at this unassuming social club in Little Italy. Hear firsthand accounts from a local who lived through the reigns of Carlo Gambino and John Gotti, as they recount how the 'Teflon Don' operated his elusive family business from this very location.
Sicilian Cannoli (Little Italy)
Conclude your Mafia experience with a delectable 'dolce'—a cream-filled Sicilian cannoli—from the best pastry shop in Little Italy. This nearly 100-year-old gem, frequented by locals and operated by close friends, offers an authentic taste of Italy, far removed from the shadows of crime but deeply rooted in the neighborhood's cultural fabric.
Cannoli (Little Italy)
Indulge in the best cannoli Little Italy has to offer, from our close friends who have operated this gem for almost 100 years. Enjoy a generously sized cannoli, a far cry from the typical mini tourist versions, and savor the authentic flavors of Sicily in this classic Italian-American neighborhood.
Know Before You Go
This tour includes a spaghetti tasting at a famous Mafia restaurant, snacks, and insider stories from retired NYPD guides. Gratuities and drinks are not included, but drinks are available for purchase. The tour operates in all weather conditions. The meeting point is in the East Village, and the tour ends in Little Italy.
Hot Tip
Wear comfortable shoes because you will be walking a lot. Also, bring some extra money if you want to buy drinks or souvenirs along the way.
Review Summary
People finds this tour highly entertaining and unique due to the authentic insider perspective from retired NYPD detectives who grew up in the area, with frequent praise for the knowledgeable guides, great food like spaghetti and cannoli, and fresh stories not found on typical tours.[2][8] Positive mentions include the well-handled large groups and engaging vibe different from average tours. No significant negatives are noted in available reviews.
This page is synthesized and developed by Dyvarcity Team
More like this
New York City
$99
Chinatown & Little Italy Food Tour: NYC's Best Bites!
5.0
(2699 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Secret Food Tour of Chinatown and Little Italy: Discover the tastes and stories behind two of New York City's most iconic neighborhoods. This walking food tour takes guests on a culinary adventure through Chinatown and Little Italy, exploring hidden gems and savoring authentic flavors.
What to Expect: Starting near Columbus Park, the tour winds through the bustling streets of Chinatown, then crosses into the charming Little Italy and Nolita. Knowledgeable guides share captivating stories about the history, culture, and food traditions of these vibrant communities. Highlights include sampling handmade fried dumplings, a secret dish, mochi donut holes, brick oven pizza, mini cannoli, and a baked roast pork bun. The tour concludes with a classic New York-style cheesecake.
This small-group walking tour ensures a personalized experience. Please note that transportation is not included, and gratuities are appreciated. Additional drinks are available for purchase along the way. This tour has excellent quality and low cancellation rate, so book with confidence! Prepare to uncover some of New York City's best-kept culinary secrets.
New York City
$130
NYC Chinatown & Little Italy Food Tour: Original Since '09
5.0
(2187 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
The Original NYC Guided Food Tour of Chinatown and Little Italy offers a delicious journey through two of New York City's most vibrant neighborhoods. Since 2009, this tour has been exploring the tastes and history of Chinatown and Little Italy, offering a unique experience for locals and visitors alike. It's a tasty way to get to know the city!
Guests will enjoy 2-3 seated tastings and 5-6 on-the-go tastings, with options for vegetarian and gluten-free diets available upon request. The tour includes water, tea, and a choice of wine or beer for those 21 and over at a seated tasting. From savory dumplings to authentic Italian meals, participants leave with a full stomach and a newfound confidence in navigating these colorful neighborhoods.
This walking food tour visits historical landmarks and explores cultural treasures. Each guest receives a helpful recommendation list and map to continue exploring after the tour. Operated by friendly guides, this tour promises an off-the-beaten-path adventure filled with fascinating stories and culinary delights.
New York City
$97.5
NYC Food Tour: Greenwich Village, Chinatown & Little Italy
5.0
(1794 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
Secret Food Tours NYC - Greenwich Village, Chinatown & Little Italy offers a tasty trip through some of New York City's most interesting neighborhoods. This food tour lets people discover hidden food spots and try famous New York foods. It is perfect for food lovers who want to experience the real flavors of the city.
In Greenwich Village, guests can enjoy a New York-style bagel with “schmear” a delicious cupcake, classic falafel, and the best New York pizza. The tour guides share stories about the area, making the food even more enjoyable. In Chinatown and Little Italy, the tour explores vibrant streets with delicious tastes around every corner. People will get to try handmade fried dumplings, baked roast pork buns, New York-style cheesecake, mochi donut holes, and mini Sicilian cannoli.
This tour includes a local guide, food tastings, and a fun way to learn about the different cultures that make New York City so special. It does not include hotel pickup and drop-off or gratuities. The tour is a small group, and the experience has excellent quality and low supplier cancellation rate.
New York City
$94.99
Greenwich Village Food Tour: Bites & Hidden Gems!
5.0
(1570 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
The Greenwich Village Walking and Food Tasting Tour lets people discover one of New York City's coolest places. This tour walks through the famous Washington Square Park, known for its big arch and appearances in movies like 'I Am Legend'. Get ready to eat tasty foods while exploring the town's history and culture.
During the Greenwich Village food tour, people can expect to visit many famous spots. These include Molly's Cupcakes, known for their yummy treats, and Mamoun's Falafel, famous for their Middle Eastern food. People will also get to try Artichoke Basille's Pizza, Pommes Frites, Kesté Pizza & Vino, and Faicco's Italian Specialties. Besides food, the tour goes by the 'Friends' Apartment Building and the Stonewall Inn, places with important stories.
This tour includes bottled water and lunch to keep people energized. It does not include tips or alcoholic drinks, but beer and wine can be bought at some stops. This is a great way to experience Greenwich Village's food and culture.
Philadelphia
$38
Dark Philly: Adult Night Tour - History, Sex & Ghosts!
4.9
(4238 reviews)
Duration: 120
minutes
The Dark Philly Adult Night Tour offers a unique perspective on Philadelphia's history, revealing the city's hidden, R-rated stories. This walking tour, led by a local professor or teacher, explores the darker side of Philadelphia's past.
Participants can expect to visit historical landmarks like the Liberty Bell and Independence Hall, but also delve into the city's secrets of sex, ghosts, and more. The tour includes stops at sites such as the President's House (George Washington's Residence), Congress Hall, Execution Grounds, and the infamous Walnut Street Prison. Guests will also see the site of Alexander Hamilton's Philadelphia home and the haunted Merchants Exchange Building.
The Dark Philly Adult Night Tour includes R-rated histories, stories about sex in 1776, and chilling ghost stories, along with abundant sightseeing. It excludes hotel pickup and drop-off services and gratuities.
New York City
$80.74
Discover Authentic Flavors: A Lower East Side Culinary Walking Tour
5.0
(643 reviews)
Duration: 180
minutes
NYC Lower East Side Walking and Food Tour: A 3-hour small-group experience exploring Manhattan's vibrant culinary scene. Led by a local guide, savor diverse foods at seven destinations while uncovering the area's rich history and ongoing transformations. Enjoy a taste of culture and cuisine.
Nearby Events
The Capitol Theatre
Jun 14
7:00 PMTheresa Caputo Live at Capitol Theatre Tickets
Theresa Caputo Live: The Experience brings the Long Island Medium to The Capitol Theatre in Port Chester, NY, for an intimate evening of spiritual connection and healing messages. Known worldwide from her television fame and new Lifetime series Raising Spirits, Caputo shares personal stories and her remarkable gift of communicating with those who have passed, delivering comfort to audiences through direct revelations from loved ones.[br]For over 30 years, Theresa Caputo has captivated more than 1.5 million people worldwide as one of the most renowned mediums, blending her life experiences with live audience readings in her bestselling author persona. The Capitol Theatre, a historic venue celebrated for its intimate atmosphere and recent honors like the 2025 Community Partner Award, provides the perfect backdrop for this awe-inspiring event.
Madison Square Garden
Mar 25
7:30 PMCardi B Little Miss Drama Tour Tickets NYC
The Cardi B - Little Miss Drama Tour is a milestone event at Madison Square Garden, New York City, showcasing Cardi B's dynamic presence in the hip-hop and rap world. This arena tour, her first-ever headlining arena run, supports her latest album Am I the Drama?* and features high-energy performances blending bold lyricism and genre fusion.
Cardi B’s rise to prominence with hits and her unapologetic persona makes this tour a cultural phenomenon. Madison Square Garden, known as the iconic venue for legendary concerts and sporting events, provides the perfect backdrop for this much-anticipated stop on the 31-city North American tour.
IMAX THEATRE at TROPICANA
Apr 22
6:00 PMMichael Early Access at IMAX Tropicana
Michael: Early Access Event brings the enigmatic artist Michael to the IMAX THEATRE at TROPICANA in Atlantic City, NJ, for an exclusive music and film fusion experience. This early access showcase highlights Michael's innovative blend of live music and cinematic visuals, drawing fans eager for his latest creative evolution in a setting optimized for immersive performances.
Michael captivates audiences with his boundary-pushing artistry, merging music and film in ways that redefine live entertainment. The IMAX THEATRE at TROPICANA, Atlantic City's only Giant Screen Certified IMAX with 290 seats and powerful sound, elevates the event with unparalleled visual and audio immersion.
Shinnecock Hills Golf Club
Jun 15
2026 US Open Golf at Shinnecock Hills Tickets
The U.S. Open Golf Championship at Shinnecock Hills Golf Club brings the world's elite players to Southampton, NY, for golf's toughest test on one of America's most historic courses.[1][2] This 126th edition promises precision, endurance, and drama as competitors vie for the coveted trophy amid wind-swept fairways and punishing rough.
The U.S. Open stands as golf's most prestigious major, challenging the best with its unrelenting demands and rich legacy of champions like Raymond Floyd, Corey Pavin, Retief Goosen, and Brooks Koepka.[2] Shinnecock Hills Golf Club, founded in 1891 as one of the USGA's five charter clubs, features a classic links-style layout redesigned by William Flynn in 1931, stretching over 7,400 yards with deep bunkers and rolling greens.[1][2]
PNC Bank Arts Center
July 12
7:30 PM"Weird Al" Yankovic Holmdel: Tickets & Info
Get ready for "Weird Al" Yankovic's Bigger & Weirder 2026 Tour at the PNC Bank Arts Center in Holmdel, NJ! This comedy extravaganza promises an evening filled with hilarious parodies, original songs, and Al's signature accordion wizardry. Known for his clever lyrics and energetic performances, "Weird Al" continues to delight fans of all ages with his unique brand of musical comedy.
"Weird Al" Yankovic has cemented his place in pop culture history with hits like "Eat It," "Like a Surgeon," and "White & Nerdy." The PNC Bank Arts Center, a beloved outdoor amphitheater, provides a fantastic setting for this unforgettable show, offering both covered and lawn seating for a comfortable concert experience.
MetLife Stadium
Aug 01
8:00 PMBTS World Tour at MetLife Stadium
BTS WORLD TOUR lights up MetLife Stadium with the global K-pop icons delivering their first headline stadium shows as a group since 2021-2022. This massive 70+ date extravaganza features a groundbreaking 360-degree in-the-round stage, immersing fans in hits like Dynamite, Butter, and Boy With Luv for an unprecedented live spectacle.
BTS, pop royalty with billions of streams and record-breaking albums, captivates with high-energy choreography and heartfelt anthems that unite ARMY worldwide. MetLife Stadium, a premier East Rutherford venue known for hosting epic concerts, provides the perfect backdrop for this historic K-pop milestone.
The Bucket List Playbook: Top Things to do in Brooklyn
Ready for adventure? Dyvarcity is your ultimate guide to the top 100 things to do in Brooklyn From must-see attractions like Short Term Availability, Music, Walking Tours & Rock in Brooklyn. We've handpicked events & experiences with passion: whether you love activities that move your body, vibrant music, sports, food, or cultural explorations.
View Brooklyn Activities